ASU HOME CRESMET Home
A Taxonomy of Barriers and Supports for Women in STEM Studies and Careers -

 

Parental/Family

School

Guidance Counselors

Social

Internal/Individual

B
a
r
r
i
e
r
s

Family members lack knowledge base in math & science; provide little help

Little encouragement in math/science

Low aspirations or expectations for success in math/science

Maternal math anxiety transmitted to daughter

Ineffective teaching methods in math &science

Little/no encouragement from teachers in math/science

Teachers unwilling to provide extra help in math/science

Not challenged in math/science classes

Inadequate academic preparation in math/science

Poor learning environment (disruptive) in math/science courses

Sexism

Disconnect between professions they considered and perceived need for math/science

Lack of understanding of preparation for various careers

Inadequate, incomplete, and mis- information from counselors about careers

Active discouragement at all educational levels

 

Social comparisons; judge science/math ability in relation to other students

Peer group not involved in math/science

Lack of success in math/science to avoid peer rejection, tokenism, and stereotype threat.

Lack of and/or negative exposure to math/science role models of same gender and/or ethnicity (family, peers, school, society, media)

Gender stereotyping

(Males viewed as superior in math/science)

Low math/science self-efficacy

Lack of interest in math/science

Misconceptions about workload/level of difficulty of math/science courses

Lack of initiative to seek out resources/help in math/science

Lack of understanding of real-world applications of math/science

 

Parental/Family

School

Guidance Counselors

Social

Internal/Individual

S
u
p
p
o
r
t
s

Family has knowledge base in math and science; provide sufficient help

Encouragement from family to do well in math/science

Support & high expectations for success in math/science career choices

Paternal encouragement is critically important

 

Effective math/science teaching methods

Encouraging science and math teachers

Math/science teachers quick to help when needed

Challenging math/science coursework

Exposure to math & science enrichment (tutors, mentors, special programs)

 

 

Counselors provide clarity to career path & appropriate information (courses needed; structure and path to science/math majors and careers)

School professionals engaged in student math and science career goals

Access to online structured career plans  (e.g., VCC)

Active encouragement of STEM careers

 

Perceived as competent in math & science by social group

Peer group involved in math and science

Strong female role models in math and science

Discuss math/science career aspirations with social group

Egalitarian gender role perspectives

 

High math/science self efficacy

Resilience-willingness to work hard in math & science

Obtained mastery experiences in math/science

Able to see application of math/science in career

Has identified math/science career goal

 

Revised from:


Hackett, G., Haag, S., & Spencer, D. A. (2006) Choosing math and science: Barriers for women, Annual Report to the National Science Foundation, Award 0429036

Fouad, N., Hackett, G., Haag, S., Kantamneni, N., Fitzpatrick, M. E. (August 2007). Career choice barriers: Environmental influences on women's career choices. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Psychological Association, San Francisco, CA.

Development area (requires authorization)